Which Diamond Clarity Should I Choose? VS1, VS2 or SI
Direct answer
For most jewelry, VS is the sweet spot: VS1 and VS2 are clean to the unaided eye, with marks visible only under magnification. A well-placed SI1 can be a smart budget move when the inclusion sits off-center and stays invisible face-up; below that, look closely at the specific stone. Flawless and near-flawless grades cost a premium the eye cannot see — for an engagement ring, VS or better is a common benchmark.
What the eye can see, and where to spend
Clarity grades describe how many internal marks (inclusions) and surface marks a stone has, as seen under 10x magnification — not with the naked eye. The scale runs from Flawless down through VVS (marks so tiny even a grader works to find them), VS (very slightly included — invisible to the eye), SI (slightly included — small marks), and lower grades where marks begin to be visible or to affect durability.
The practical cut-off for most pieces is VS, because at VS1–VS2 the stone is clean in normal viewing conditions. Above VS, the price climbs for perfection that only magnification reveals. Below it, SI1 is where the honest budget trade lives: a well-placed SI1 inclusion — under a prong, off to the side — can be truly invisible face-up, while a dark inclusion under the table can look worse than a VS stone at twice the price. Grade plus placement is the real answer.
Two tiebreakers when you are torn. For daily-wear and engagement pieces, VS or better is the common benchmark — durability and peace of mind, not only vanity: prominent inclusions can also matter for how a stone takes a setting and wears over decades. And if the budget is fixed, an SI1 with a well-placed inclusion and a great cut beats a sleepy VVS — ask for photos or video of the actual stone and judge placement, which is what you will live with.
This is part of our guide on Materials & Gemstones.
More questions on this
Can I see inclusions in VS1 or VS2?+
Not with the unaided eye. VS means very slightly included — the marks are visible only under magnification, which is why it is the standard recommendation for rings.
Is SI1 good enough?+
Often yes — when the inclusion is small and placed off-center or hidden by a prong. It is a placement judgement: ask to see the actual stone.
Should I pay for VVS or flawless?+
Rarely. The premium buys clarity only a microscope can see. Most buyers are better served putting that money into cut or carat.
Have a question we didn't answer?
Send it with your idea — a real person at the factory replies, usually within a business day.